Scallops truly are the candy of the sea, and it’s rare that I can pass them up when I see them on a restaurant menu. But I’ve always been hesitant to make them. The first time I tried to sear scallops at home, they emitted a strange milky liquid and ended up steaming more than searing. They were still tasty, but disappointing. I’ve since learned that those scallops must have been “wet” scallops—treated with yummy-sounding sodium tripolyphosphate, which is apparently often the case with supermarket scallops. What you want to get, it seems, are “dry” scallops. (According to Cook’s Illustrated, if you’re not sure what you have, place one scallop on a paper-towel lined plate and microwave for 15 seconds; if it’s, wet, it will release liquid. And then, if you do have wet scallops, soak them in a solution of one quart cold water, 1/4 cup lemon juice, and two tablespoons table salt for 30 minutes.)
Still, disheartened by my first attempt. it took me nearly two years to try again. I’m deeply sorry that I waited so long.

It was difficult to stop eating long enough to take this photo.
Armed with Cook’s Illustrated’s science—and the suggestion of using butter—I finally found the nerve to give it another shot. Way to go, science! And butter! Sea scallops are still frustratingly expensive, but with this technique they make for an insanely quick and fabulous weeknight supper.
(more…)